Netgear AC1200 vs AC1900 Comparison [2020 UPDATED]

If you are here, then you are probably experiencing some sort of dilemma in the battle of the ACs, Netgear AC1200 vs AC1900. Probably related to what kind of WiFi adapter will be a better suit for you. We are spot on, are we not?

You came to the right place and we will help solve that dilemma with a review between the two giant Netgear AC1900 vs AC1200.

In this particular review (Netgear AC1200 vs AC1900), we will be covering the AC1200 and AC1900 wireless routers. In addition to that, there will also be a discussion about two USB adapter antennas. Both of which are named after their respective routers.

Recommended: Netgear ac3000 vs ac2200 Comparison.

When do I choose a router or adapter?

Netgear AC1200 vs AC1900 Comparison

Before anything else, let us give you a quick rundown of the reasons why these guys are better than the others.

            AC1200s

  • Has amazing remote access features
  • A snug fit for smaller houses
  • Provides good internet for general use

            AC1900s

  • Perfect router for gaming and streaming purposes
  • Have strong parental control
  • The range is superior compared to the others

            AC1200 Adapter

  • Can be set up without any hitch
  • Very compatible with Windows personal computers
  • Backward compatible with USB ports and routers of the previous generations

            AC1900 Adapter

  • It is very fast
  • Having a dual-band connection
  • High compatibility with both Windows and Mac

Key Features of the Netgear AC1200

NETGEAR AC1200 Dual Band Wi-Fi Router

CLICK HERE TO CHECK AC1200 PRICE ON AMAZON

Even though the AC1200 is already a bit out of date, it still offers strong speedy performance, good range, stability, and multitudes of security features. There is also the Nighthawk app which allows the user to easily turn on and off the internet service. This is very useful to those who are running public networks.

The AC1200’s forte lies in its reliability. Through the long years of its existence, it has been tested and refined over and over again. Because of this, all rough edges are all smoothened out.

All of its firmware, hardware, and mobile application do not have any bugs or problems left. They have all been fixed and are basically rock solid.

For all these reasons, it basically points to one thing. It is far more consistent than the other routers on the market. The router will never need to do some power recycling frequency. Although, this kind of reliability needs some kind of same value exchange. This is not really a good choice for long term use.

Oh, we are not saying that its durability will fall. It can certainly outlast most routers currently available today. It is just that it can no longer give the same amount of performance and packet prioritization as newer routers can provide.

If you are just playing games personally and not taking anything seriously, then you probably will not even notice anything wrong. However, if you have some serious business or a large number of users utilizing the network, then such a feature may be a downfall so be sure to consider these factors still.

Here are some pros and cons.

Pros

  • Has dual bands with two networks
  • Can support up to six devices connected to it
  • Has 1200 Mbps speed
  • Can easily be controlled with a mobile app

Cons

  • Lacks some quality of service features
  • Traffic cannot be prioritize
  • Firmware and hardware are quite on the older scale
  • The Port is a USB 2.0 port

Key Features of the Netgear AC1900

Netgear AC1900

CLICK HERE TO CHECK AC1900 PRICE ON AMAZON

The AC1900 is some sci-fi Esque router. It is as future-proof as any wireless router can be. There is no immediate problem with it being outdated.

The AC1900’s set of amazing features and multitudes of optimizations makes it the perfect choice for all kinds of houses.

Of course, that’s not all its set of features can offer. Said features are specially designed for gaming and streaming. That means that it has the quality of service options and prioritizes real-time traffic than those that just browse the web. This also means that you can wring the most out of your internet connection. Not like the other routers.

If you are into internet stuff, then the AC1900 is the perfect choice to pick. It can support a lot of devices all at once and even has multiple software tools to allow you to manage them all.

The dual-band feature allows you to get two separate networks at your own discretion. That means you can connect your devices to a 2.4 GHz network, all the while your PCs are connected to the larger 5 GHz networks. Now, that is some nifty feature.

If you keep your traffic separated just like this, those devices which require the faster speed can get what they need. Of course, vice versa also applies. In addition to that, having two bands also means that you do not have to worry about getting weak signals in crowded areas. It does some magic and gets around local interference. Win-win.

Here are some pros and cons of the AC1900

Pros

  • Can prioritize traffic for gaming and video streaming needs
  • Has superior specs like range, firmware, and hardware
  • Compatible with both USB 2.0 and USB 3.0
  • Can support a lot of connected devices

Cons

  • A bit hard to configure beyond the basic setup
  • Has a weak remote access capability
  • Presence of problems when it comes to hardware reliability

Key Features of AC1200 Adapter

The good thing about this adapter is it also shares the same speed with its namesake. It can go up to 1200 Mbps.

The difference between its closely related router cousin is that its sole purpose is to receive wireless signals. It cannot be used to set up a network or the like.

This essentially means that the AC1200 adapter is only useful if your device does not have a wireless card on its motherboard. If that is not the case, focus on the two above.

On the other hand, your laptop is from the previous era and you want to get some extra mileage out of it, getting this may still be a good decision.

This is actually good for an adapter. It has USB 3.0 but is compatible with USB 2.0. This is especially important if your laptop is from the olden days.

This adapter also has some good range, decent speed, and satisfactory stability. The firmware is supposed to be plug-and-play. After that, just let it sulk as much as it wants. No touching, no moving. If what you are looking for is revamping that old laptop to let it you travel with it more effectively, then consider this adapter.

The AC1200 uses a decent amount of power to the device it is plugged on. It does not really have any flashy feature that drains your battery like there is no tomorrow.

Read Also: Netgear ac1200 vs Linksys ac1200.

Here are the pros and cons of the AC1200.

Pros

  • Compatible with older devices
  • Can reach up to 1200 Mbps speed
  • Has a high-gain antenna
  • Set up will not give you any trouble

Cons

  • Not compatible with Mac
  • QR code is bad with its job and does not work well
  • More of a home tech rather than a travel tech

Key Features of the AC1900 Adapter

Unlike the intimate relationship between the AC1200s relationship, this adapter only shares its name with the router. It is compact and powerful compared to its bigger-bodied cousin.

There are also more differences with the AC1200. This adapter is first and foremost, compatible with both PCs and Macs. No discrimination out here.

If you are using a Mac from the olden day, this adapter is basically your only option.

This is also quite fast and also has two bands to evade that crowded area. The difference also becomes wider, the AC1900 has a magnetic cradle which can be detached from the main adapter. This allows you to use the cradle to look for places with stronger signals. In addition to that, magnetism does its magic to any metal surface. Pretty handy.

Although, there is one concern. The magnet is quite strong enough to damage the screen of older models. This should not be an issue as long as you do not store these two in one compartment inside your bag. If you do, do not blame us or tell us we did not warn you.

This also has an app that allows you to change how it functions. Though, a lot of users do not really have any problems with the simple plug and play. In addition to that, this thing got speed. It can reach a speed of up to 1900 Mbps.

We guess one thing that is a downside of being a newer model is not really having that much of backward compatibility. A feature that the AC1200 excels at. You will need to have an operating system that should at least be Windows 7 or Mac OS X 10.8.3. Otherwise, the adapter will not do anything.

In addition to that, the cost of having a high speed and wide range is getting your battery drained faster. This could be quite an issue if your laptop is quite old since the battery drainage counteracts the advantage of portability.

If what you are looking for is some low-powered wireless adapter, the AC1200 is the better option. Though that consequently means having less range and slower speed.

Here are the AC1900 adapter’s pros and cons.

NETGEAR Nighthawk Smart WiFi Router (R7000)

Pros

  • Compatible with most hardware and software setups in the broader sense
  • Can reach up to 1900 Mbps speed
  • Has a 3×4 MIMO design which means superior downloading and uploading speed
  • Amazing speed

Cons

  • Drains battery quite fast
  • A bit difficult to position the antenna
  • Having a magnetic cradle is both its strength and weakness

Final Thoughts

The choice should always boil down to whatever your needs are. If you think that you will be doing a lot of online gaming and video streaming at home and a lot of people will be sharing the connection with you, the AC1900 is the better choice. Choosing the AC1900 guarantees that you will not be needing to think about buying another router for a good amount of time.

The AC1900’s features like the packet prioritization, good range, amazing speed, and dependable security options make it stand out among the crowd. However, if you are willing to compromise a bit of speed to get some reliability, the AC1200 is the better choice. It is putting its money on being proven and tested than some flashy features.

It boasts of having good stability with its long history with users and fixes, as well as having a solid firmware. Just do take note that some cool features and parental controls will be compromised and you are good to go.

Again, if you are still pondering which adapter to buy, then that heavily relies on which hardware you possess. If you are using a Mac, then that automatically means that you should get the AC1900. If you have a PC, it depends on what kind of operating system you have. If it is part of the newer ones, the AC1900 is better since it is quite future-proof. But if your OS is not quite recent, you can only choose the AC1200 due to compatibility issues.

Anyway, both adapters do offer dual-band WiFi systems and provide decent speed. They also both have decent security features and firmware too!